• Recent Sermons
    • Jonah Series
    • 25-26 Sermons
    • Leadership
    • Anglican
    • Community
    • Values & Vision
    • Calendar
    • Sundays
    • Feasts
  • Contact
  • Giving
  • Blog
Menu

All Saints - Anglican - Honolulu, Hawaii

Honolulu, HI
..............................
8082774429
Anglican Church in Honolulu, Hawaii

Your Custom Text Here

All Saints - Anglican - Honolulu, Hawaii

  • Sermons
    • Recent Sermons
    • Jonah Series
    • 25-26 Sermons
  • About
    • Leadership
    • Anglican
    • Community
    • Values & Vision
    • Calendar
  • Worship
    • Sundays
    • Feasts
  • Contact
  • Giving
  • Blog
blob

Da Blog

When ideals become idols

November 17, 2026 Mark Brians

p/c Chapman Chow via unsplash

Part 5 of a multi-part series on church culture in a growing parish.

“In Christian brotherhood everything depends upon its being clear right from the beginning, first, that Christian brotherhood is not an ideal, but a divine reality” writes Dietrich Bonhoeffer (26). He writes reflecting on his experience living with and leading the seminary community at Finkenwalde.

All around the students at Finkenwalde Europe was being swallowed up, it seemed, on all sides by communities built around ideals: racial purity, communism, solidarism, dialectical criticism, free love, fascism, sovietism, etc. All of these movements are consumed by a sense of discontent and of striving to attain the ideal.

The Christian community, however, must not be established around our ideals. She must be established by the Divine Reality of Christ’s presence in the Church, in Word and Sacrament and the shared Life of God’s people.

Bu what does this mean? Isn’t it good to have things like visions statements, values, mission goals? Well sure! Of course!

But those ideals, as soon as they cease to be merely goals, as soon as they take the place of the Divine Center of the Gospel, become horrible death-dealing things. As soon as they limit my ability to love and give thanks for the community of saints-in-progress with whom I actually worship and serve and pray these ideals become instruments of torture.

Our ideals very quickly become idols.

Our ideals make us petulant children “No! Not until I have reshaped these people into the image I have in my mind when I think of ‘church’ will I be happy!”

We struggle to press into the messy, often jagged, not fully perfected bunch of sinners that my church actually is, all the wishing they were closer to the way I had hoped.

“Innumerable times a whole Christian community has broken down because it had sprung from a wish dream. The serious Christian, set down for the first time in a Christian community, is likely to bring with him a very definite idea of what Christian life together should be and to try to realize it” (26).

We become disillusioned. “It’s just so hard for me to enter into worship with all these kids running around” we think, or “Once we hit 250 average Sunday attendance then I will breathe easy” or “If only we were more liturgical then I’ll be happy” or “If only we were less liturgical then I would be at peace."

I elevate my longings and my values to the detriment of my ability to be fully present here-and-now with Christ as He offers Himself to me in here-and-now in this local body of believers.

I grow disillusioned with life. “Forget it” we think, “what’s the point? Is any of this real (if it’s not meeting my ideals immediately)?"

But disillusionment of this kind is precisely the work that the Spirit is doing in the local body of believers. It is God’s grace which “speedily shatters such dreams” —dreams of everything going the way I feel owed to have it go.

“Just as surely as God desires to lead us to a knowledge of genuine Christian fellowship, so surely must we be overwhelmed by a great disillusionment with others, with Christians in general, and, if we are fortunate, with ourselves” (26-27).

I am counted among the things which have shattered my romantic dreams about “being authentic” my sentimental wish dreams about Christian community. And it has been the gracious Will of God which has done so. This is because “[e]very human wish dream that is injected into the Christian community is a hindrance to genuine community and must be banished if genuine community is to survive” (27).

To quote Bonhoeffer at some length:

“God hates visionary dreaming; it makes the dreamer proud and pretentious. The man who fashions a visionary ideal of community demands that it be realized by God, by others, and by himself. He enters the community of Christians with his demands, sets up his own law, and judges the brethren and God Himself accordingly. He stands adamant, a living reproach to all others in the circle of heaven. He acts as if he is the creator of the Christian community as if his dream binds men together. When things do not go his way, he calls the effort a failure. When his ideal picture is destroyed, he sees the community going to smash. So he becomes, first an accuser of hsi brethren, then an accuser of God, and finally the despairing accuser of himself” (28).

To follow the Living God is a ruinous thing —ruinous especially for our ideals of the way my home parish should be. I go to Church with fleshy ideals and arrive only find the broken individuals among whom Christ is at work and among whom I am counted a member.

I’ve spent a lot of time in these entries talking about belonging and differences. I want to pause for a moment to consider the pain and disillusionment of parish life. When we were smaller it was easy, because of our natural closeness and the sense that everyone knew everyone, to assume a lot of ideals about what our parish was and what it would become. A couple of church-plants and a bunch of baptisms latter many of us in our current stage might be tempted to look around and say “where’s the cute little church-plant I once knew?” or to work to shape All Saints HNL, as it grows, into the image of our ideal church community.

But God is not interested in those things, our cute little ideals. He has ruined, so it seems, the cute little church-plant we once had. Thanks be to God! He has laid that cute church-plant in a tomb in the ground with his Son and has raised her up into the glory of her current size and composition of persons. And, because He loves her, he will again bring us through death and into a new resurrection season.

Each moment in which I encounter a disillusionment, the collapse of an ideal (e.g. “the people at this church will never offend me”) there is sounding the wind of the Spirit, hovering over us, inviting us to press into the struggle with one another in our common life together.

Every disillusionment I encounter in my life in the Church is an opportunity to find God’s Grace made perfect in my weakness. “This is not what I thought things would be like” is the musical prelude we offer before the symphony of “The way God would have things be.”

Tags community, church, church relationships, ideals, Community, Bonhoeffer, disillusionment
Say 'no' to church parties →
Summary Block
This block is invalid. Please check the block settings and try again.
Featured
Aenean eu leo Quam
Aenean eu leo Quam

Quisque iaculis facilisis lacinia. Mauris euismod pellentesque tellus sit amet mollis.

Read more →
© ALL SAINTS ANGLICAN CHURCH